Skip to content
Return to nav
Photo of James Herrholtz

James Herrholtz

Rating 4.9
Farmers Insurance Agent in Mentor, OH
Call MeCall Me

Contact Info


7200 Center St
Ste 105
Mentor, OH 44060

Get Directions

Phone Numbers

(440) 527-0304(440) 527-0304
(440) 527-0304

Office Hours

Day of the WeekHours
Mon:8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Tue:8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Wed:8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Thu:8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Fri:8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Contact me

Farmers Insurance Agent in Mentor, OH

Herrholtz Insurance Agency Inc
About Me

Rating 4.9

As your local Farmers® agent in Mentor, OH, I help customers like you identify the insurance coverage that best fits your needs. This process is straightforward and personalized to help make you smarter about insurance. I have the knowledge and experience to help you better understand your coverage options--whether that's auto, home, renters, business insurance and more.

Give me a call at (440) 527-0304 and I'll be happy to answer any questions you might have.

Languages Spoken: English

Years of Experience

I have over 10 years of experience as a Farmers Insurance agent.


MA, Youngstown State University, BA, Youngstown State University, and Hubbard High School

Neighborhoods Served

Madison, Geneva, Cleveland, Chardon, and Kirtland


Insurance Products Offered

Business Insurance

Ask Me About:

Piggy bank with pile of coins shaped like the continental US

As your local Farmers agent in Mentor, I can help make you smarter about insurance.

Depending on your state, you may be eligible for certain discounts. See how Farmers can save you money on insurance specific to Ohio residents.


Life insurance can help you to provide financial support for the ones you love if something happens to you.

PWS LD-02 10/17
Has your business grown since we last reviewed your business insurance? If so, let’s have a conversation so you can decide if your level of coverage is keeping up with your level of success. Call me today
The personalized service that comes with your Farmers auto coverage might be the best recommendation for adding a Farmers homeowners policy to your insurance portfolio. When you purchase an additional policy, you might also qualify for a multi-line discount. Call me today for more information.
On a motorcycle, you can experience the road as you want, without barriers or boundaries. And with Farmers, you can choose the coverage you want, with potentially specialized options like coverage for accessories and trip interruptions. Call me today to learn more.
Introducing the new My Farmers - now managing your insurance is simpler and more convenient than ever. With the new look and feel, My Farmers gives you access to your insurance at your convenience, from almost any device.

We've completely redesigned the My Farmers experience, giving you easy access to:

- Pay bills and manage payment options
- Print your digital ID card
- View your agents' information
- View valuable perks
- Policy documents all in one place
- Sign up for bill and new document notifications

Recent Reviews for James Herrholtz

Rating 4.9
40 Customer Reviews
  • Rating 5.0
    Had a great experience working with him on home insurance, outstanding prices and when he says he can beat the pants off competitors believe him.
  • Rating 5.0
    James has been great to work with on Insurance, as i'm not a huge fan of insurance, he has been very helpful in navigating through all the in's and out's of Insurance. It has been GREAT to work with him and i am happy that i have switched to James as my insurance agent.
  • Rating 5.0
    Was responsive. Told me things other agents did not to help reduce my costs and did what he said he would when he said he would
  • Rating 5.0
    Very easy to talk to and work with. Exceeded our expectations! Thanks Jim!!!!
  • Rating 5.0
    Jim is a legend. Thanks for saving us big time!
  • Rating 5.0
    I cannot express how grateful I am to have Mr. Herrholtz as my agent! He truly has gone above and beyond to not only provide me with excellent coverage with excellent rates, but to be on hand to answer all of my questions promptly. It alleviated stress from my first home purchase and I cannot thank him enough for his extraordinary effort he provided for me. I look forward to being a client for years to come!
  • Rating 5.0
    Amazing service!
  • Rating 4.0
    Maddy was very knowledgeable and kind. I have been so stressed through purchasing my first home, I felt no one really cared about me through the entire process; until I called the Herrholtz Agency! Maddy had a quote prepared for me during the phone conversation, and by the end of the call I had the exact coverage I wanted along with some knowledge on Insurance that will help me the rest of my life. Thank you Herrholtz Insurance!!!
  • Rating 5.0
    I cannot express how wonderful it is to work with such a great team. They were easy to deal with and understood our families needs. Top notch agency
  • Rating 5.0
    I was referred to Farmers/James Herrholtz by a friend. I had great customer service and my policies were written and put in to action very quickly. I am pleased with my experience at Farmers, Thank You!
  • Rating 5.0
    Excellent man with high character as a person great job!
  • Rating 5.0
    I am very happy with the results I received and look forward to continuing my services with Farmers insurance. Thank you!!
  • Rating 5.0
    Jim and his staff were able to save us on insurance costs while improving our coverage. He kept things simple and straight forward without having to go through the details repeatedly as did so many of the competitors. We look forward to dealing with Farmers Insurance.
  • Rating 5.0
    Madilyn Herrholtz has been amazing to work with. She has provided very timely responses to all of my questions. She is very personable and makes the customer feel appreciated. Will definitely recommend to others!
  • Rating 4.0
    Satisfied so far
  • Rating 5.0
    I think it would be difficult to have had a better experience than the one I had with this agent. I was also interested in auto insurance and I actually felt bad that the prices of my present company's policy were so much lower than you could offer.
    Best regards,
    Dave D.
  • Rating 5.0
    Ian Scott was very easy to work with and gave me an informative overview of a homeowners policy that met our needs. I appreciate his understanding of our personal situation and his efforts to get us the coverage we needed.

    Thank you , Karen
  • Rating 5.0
    So glad they followed up with me off an online quote that I thought was too high. They came in with confidence. Very professional. Very accommodating and listened to my concerns and needs. Got me exactly what I needed and wanted. So glad they know their business!!
  • Rating 5.0
    My Experience with Mr. Herrholtz has been nothing but amazing. He’s the kind of person you want on your side. He’s takes the time and effort to really help and he listen. AMAZING job.....
  • Rating 5.0
    The agent that handled my new policy was very helpful and patient with me. Im really glad I went with Farmers because of the personal attention I received.
Displaying 1 - 3 reviews of the 20 most recent