Skip to content
Return to nav
COVID-19 Relief: Learn more about how Farmers is responding to the coronavirus situation.
Photo of Paul Benjamin

Paul Benjamin

Rating 4.8
Farmers Insurance Agent in Fishers, IN
Call MeCall Me

Contact Info


11091 Village Square Ln
Fishers, IN 46038

Get Directions

Phone Numbers

(317) 602-7300(317) 602-7300
(317) 863-7505

Office Hours

Day of the WeekHours
Mon:8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Tue:8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Wed:8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Thu:8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Fri:8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Additional hours and days by appointment
Contact me

Farmers Insurance Agent in Fishers, IN

Paul Benjamin
About Me

Rating 4.8

As a longtime resident of Indiana and an Indiana Wesleyan University graduate, I am proud to serve the Fishers area as your local Farmers Insurance® agent. I also serve the surrounding cities and towns. Whether it's online, over the phone, or in person, contact me to start a conversation about home, auto, business, life insurance and more.

At our agency, we believe in educating my clients on the importance of insurance. We look to get to know our customers on a personal level first, before making any big decisions or bringing insurance into the conversation.

We understand that insurance is one of the many assets that make up your portfolio. That’s why we take a comprehensive approach when looking at your overall picture to provide you with a solution for your specific lifestyle. We want to make sure that you understand the value of being covered, and how to better protect your future!

Whether you're looking to sign a new policy or simply evaluate what you have already, We're here for all of your insurance needs. Let me use my 5+ years of insurance experience to help you discover the right insurance products for your life, to protect all that is most important to you.

Give me a call at (317) 602-7300 and I'll be happy to answer any questions you might have.

Languages Spoken: English

Years of Experience

I have over 3 years of experience as a Farmers Insurance agent.

Neighborhoods Served

Fishers, Indianapolis, Carmel, Nobelsville, and Westfield


Insurance Products Offered

Business Insurance

Ask Me About:

Piggy bank with pile of coins shaped like the continental US

As your local Farmers agent in Fishers, I can help make you smarter about insurance.

Depending on your state, you may be eligible for certain discounts. See how Farmers can save you money on insurance specific to Indiana residents.


There are so many variables to consider when choosing homeowners insurance. But Farmers Smart Plan Home® can simplify your decision with customizable packages! Call me today to learn more.

Subject to restrictions.
The personalized service that comes with your Farmers homeowners coverage might be the best recommendation for adding a Farmers auto policy to your insurance portfolio. When you purchase an additional policy, you might also qualify for a multi-line discount. Call me today for more information.
  • Keyboard player in a classic rock band
  • Family and church activities
  • Woodworking and home improvement
  • Live music events
New baby? Getting married? Life Insurance can help you provide a financial safety net. Let’s discuss your life changes!

PWS LD-01 10/17
No two companies are exactly alike. That’s why you can build a customized Farmers business insurance policy with options that provide coverage for your specific needs and challenges. Call me today to learn more.

Recent Reviews for Paul Benjamin

Rating 4.8
9 Customer Reviews
  • Rating 5.0
    Paul was responsive to our inquiries. Very helpful
    Response from Paul
    Welcome to Farmers Insurance, Chris, and thank you so much for your kind words. Very happy to be able to help with the right coverage for you.
  • Rating 5.0
    Paul was so incredibly patient with us and answered all of our questions. He asked us questions in order to really customize our policy to our needs and gave his genuine recommendations for coverage. We felt so at ease with him, and really felt that we trusted him! It is clear that he cares about and is invested in his work and it shows through how he treats his clients. This is the best experience that my husband and I have ever had acquiring insurance and we are so glad that we went to him!
    Response from Paul
    Thank you so much for your kind narrative, Alisa! I will always strive to make sure you have the appropriate coverage at the best possible rate, along with prompt response to customer service needs, and answers to all your questions.
  • Rating 5.0
    I was assigned to Paul via the internet when I applied for insurance. He is very knowledgable, professional, answered all my questions .
    Response from Paul
    Thank you for your kind words, Cindy. I'm pleased I was able to help you, and I look forward to providing you great service for years to come!
  • Rating 4.0
    I like your service
    Response from Paul
    Thank you for the review, Hieu. I will always strive to maintain that level of service!
  • Rating 5.0
    I'm pleased that Farmers could provide homeowners and auto coverage.
    Response from Paul
    Thank you for your review, Margaret. I'm pleased I was able to help you, and I look forward to providing you great service for years to come!
  • Rating 5.0
    Best service from Paul, he’s always helped me when I ask for his assistance plus I feel he goes above and beyond to answer all of our questions. I hope all agents are as awesome as my agent Paul Benjamin!
    Response from Paul
    Thanks so much for your kind review, Roonthiva. Congrats to you and Jon on your new home!
  • Rating 5.0
    I was looking for insurance and I was presented with insurance plus. This experience was the best in all of my many years of buying insurance. The agent presented his best policy- honesty. Then, of course, there his presentation of a package for auto and home. Plus, the full, extra coverage called the umbrella
    coverage which 'covered' the other two areas.

    The conversation was more like a magnet drawing one to the deal, rather than cornering the customer to accept the offer.
    Response from Paul
    Jerry, thank you so much for your kind words. It is a pleasure and a privilege to be your insurance agent.
  • Rating 5.0
    Paul was outstanding in every way !
    Response from Paul
    Thank you so much for the kind words!
  • Rating 5.0
    Paul responded to my requirements and did not push me when it was not appropriate to do so. Can't ask for much more.
    Response from Paul
    Thank you so much for your kind review, John! I will always strive to maintain that trust.
Displaying 1 - 3 reviews of 9

My Hardworking Team

Photo of Sara Dawson

Sara Dawson

Customer Service Manager

Phone :