Skip to content
Return to nav
Michael Mayer
Rating 4.9
4.9 out of 5
(275 Reviews)
Select a product to get a quote
Enter your zip code

Farmers Insurance Agent in St Augustine, FL

Michael Mayer

Mayer Insurance Agency LLC
Rating 4.9
4.9 out of 5
(275 Reviews)
8:30 AM - 5:30 PM 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM 8:30 AM - 12:00 PMClosed Today

Quote & buy online

Contact info
Location info
Location Icon
300 Kingsley Lake Dr
Ste 402
St Augustine, FL 32092
Office hours
Day of the WeekHours
Monday8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Tuesday8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Wednesday8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Thursday8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Friday8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Saturday8:30 AM - 12:00 PM

About Michael Mayer

As a long-time Florida resident, I'm proud to serve St Augustine and the surrounding areas as your local Farmers Insurance® agent. In the years I've spent living here, I have grown to understand the unique complexities that come with insuring your home, car, or business in the community that we live in. I aim to use my expertise to help make you smarter about your insurance options - whether that be home, auto, business, life insurance, and more!

At the Mayer Agency, we emphasize our proper risk management for you and your family. We will take the time to get to know and understand all of your assets in order to provide you with an efficient and easy-to-read coverage proposal. From there, you will have access to any and all policies provided by Farmers with the option to modify your policy at any point.

Feel free to stop by our office, which is conveniently located off of Route 210 or email us at for faster service. With over 30 years of insurance industry experience, I have the knowledge and skillset to help you better understand your coverage options. I look forward to working with you, your family, and any commercial business you may have, to make sure that you are properly and affordably covered.

Give me a call at (904) 500-3276 and I'll be happy to answer any questions you might have.


Years of experience

I have over 1 year of experience as a Farmers Insurance agent.
Languages spoken
English and Spanish


Bachelor of Science, New York Institute of Technology.

Neighborhoods Served

Nocatee, Julington Creek Plantation, Bartram, Silver Leaf, and Palencia

States licensed in


Insurance products offered

Get a quote online

Auto Insurance
Auto InsuranceArrow Icon
Home Insurance
Home InsuranceArrow Icon

Call for more info

Ask me about

The Mayer Agency takes a personalized approach to ensure our clients are ready to take on their current needs and future goals. We are prepared to present our customers with options and choices to different policy levels of coverage.

When it comes to Homeowners' Insurance in Florida, we are happy to discuss the specific components of your policy, such as wind mitigation. We are also well-versed in your available discounts and credits.

In crafting a policy, we will focus on common concerns such as (a) deductibles and how they factor into perils and hurricanes and (b) roof condition.

Give us a call today, and we'll be happy to discuss the best possible option for your Homeowners' Coverage as a Florida resident!

Please also feel free to click the link below to learn more about what goes into a standard Homeowners' policy.

The personalized service that comes with your Farmers homeowners coverage might be the best recommendation for amending your insurance portfolio. When you purchase an additional policy, you might also qualify for a multi-line discount. Call me today for more information.

No two companies are exactly alike. That’s why you can build a customized Farmers business insurance policy with options that provide coverage for your specific needs and challenges. Call me today to learn more.

At Farmers® we've seen almost everything, so we know how to cover almost anything – like a bear turning a garage upside down. So do you have a plan for the unexpected? I'm happy to lay out the insurance options for you to select the coverage you want.

Farmers® agents provide this service in person or online to help you review your existing coverage, so you can decide how to keep up with your changing insurance needs.

- As your life changes, maybe your policy should too

Changes in your life can add up to changes in insurance needs. A change in marital status, the birth of a child or the purchase of a new home are just a few examples of life events that may create overlaps or gaps in your coverage.

- Review your coverage and possibly save money

Just as you continue to change and grow, Farmers® has been growing for over 85 years. A Farmers® customer can be the first to enjoy access to new benefits (like when we became the first insurance group to offer a discount for alternative-fuel vehicles). Talk to us about a Farmers Friendly Review® - we can provide you with insurance options and discuss any available discounts for which you may qualify so you can select the coverage that best fits your needs.

- How often should you have a Farmers Friendly Review® session?

We recommend a Farmers Friendly Review® at least once a year or whenever you have a qualifying life event change. If you like, I can even set a reminder for us to keep an annual appointment to discuss your changing coverage needs.

Give us a call to set up your Farmers Friendly Review®.

On a motorcycle, you can experience the road as you want, without barriers or boundaries. With Farmers, you can choose the coverage you want, with potentially specialized options like coverage for accessories and trip interruptions. Call me today to learn more.

Frequently asked questions